Party Planning Guides

Need help planning? Check out one of our Planning Guides!
Pink Ribbon
Men's Health Awareness
Alice in Wonderland
See the rest!

Same Day Shipping

Most in-stock orders placed by 5:00pm ET ship the same business day!
Get details

110% Price Guarantee

Guaranteed lowest price. We’re so confident that we have the best prices that if you find a better price, we’ll beat it by 10%.
Click here for details
Price Guarantee

Making People Smile

"Shipment arrived on time. They ran out of 1 item I had ordered but called me immediatetly to ask if I would like to replace it with something else or a refund. This was great! I much rather they call me than be surprised when the package arrives with a missing item."

"Happy Birthday Jesus" Pencils

Item No: 163-1386 


1–11 $2.59
12–35 $2.30
36–119 $2.00
120+ $1.80
52 In Stock
Need More?
Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas

Have an even merrier Christmas season with “Happy Birthday Jesus” Pencils. These religious holiday pencils are the perfect seasonal favors for church Christmas celebrations and holiday youth group sessions.

  • 12 Christmas pencils per package.
  • Pencils are approximately 7½″ in length.
  • Red and green pencils in every package.

Make memories this Christmas with fun holiday favors, toys, and gifts. Stock up on everything you need to make your Christmas season complete!

We Also Recommend…

Sale - Plush Merry Christmas Stocking - Sale Christmas Activity Bookmarks
Sale - Plush Merry Christmas Stocking - Sale
from $1.99 (ea)
Christmas Activity Bookmarks
from $2.59 (pkg12)
Fill In The Blank Crazy Christmas Stories Assorted Snowflake Sticky Notepads
Fill In The Blank Crazy Christmas Stories
from $4.95 (pkg12)
Assorted Snowflake Sticky Notepads
from $6.95 (pkg12)
Drum Notepads  
Drum Notepads
from $2.95 (pkg12)

Click to write your own review!

Or see step-by-step instructions here
Christmas pencils -
K of C Aux, Cape Coral, FL

Our K oc C Aux. has adopted a classroom (1st grade) at our parish school, St. Andrew's. We put together little treat bags for the class during seasonal events. I wanted something special for the Christmas pencils and I really got it. These pencils are darling and perfect for the age level and season. I'll be back for the next holiday!
Average Rating:

Your Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty.

Your Wish List

Please log in.

Your Account

  • Simplify checkout
  • Create a wish list
  • Track your orders
  • Write product reviews

How Can We Help?

Call Us

(800) 325-6232

We're available 24/7!

Customer Service


Try it – you'll like it! But if you don't, many items can be returned up to 30 days later. No questions asked!

Earning Your Trust

Acceptance Mark
Read Your Store Reviews
BizRate Customer Certified (GOLD) Site

Safe and Secure